Top 5 afc strikers

[Guest]

Velicka

Chalali 

Zola 

Paton 

Daal

[Zeus]

Þórarinn Brynjar Kristjánsson

Lubo Blaha

Fernando Pasquenelli

Stephen Craig

Darren Mackie 

[Zeus]

Thanks MT, appreciated 

[The Cockney Don]

Duncan Shearer

Mark McGhee

Scott Booth

Eric Black

Adam Rooney.

[Crashnyploshnit]

In any list Harper and Jarvie must be included.

[Fridge]

In all seriousness and in my era.

Shearer.

Dodds.

Winters

Stavrum despite always being offside.

Jess.

 

 

[The Cockney Don]

23 minutes ago, Crashnyploshnit said:

In any list Harper and Jarvie must be included.

Even if they was before the posters time ?

I only started following the Dons in 1980/81, so couldn't include Harper, and missed the best of Jarvie.

Jarvie, Dodds, Hewitt and McDougall were the four others to miss out in my top 5.

Probably Stavrum as well to make my 10.

[aberdeen1970]

1. Harper

2. McDougall 

3. Shearer 

4. Black 

5. Archibald 

 

[WesthillWanderersFC]

18 minutes ago, Crashnyploshnit said:

In any list Harper and Jarvie must be included.

I didn’t count Drew Jarvie as a striker.

i was thinking about old fashioned no.9’s. 
Excellent player & servant to the club though 

[The Cockney Don]

13 minutes ago, WesthillWanderersFC said:

I didn’t count Drew Jarvie as a striker.

i was thinking about old fashioned no.9’s. 
Excellent player & servant to the club though 

Centre Forward i think is the words you are looking for.

[WesthillWanderersFC]

Just now, The Cockney Don said:

Centre Forward i think is the words you are looking for.

Aye, true ?

[aberdeen1970]

I was only considering what I'd call main strikers too. 

If we're including other 'forwards' then that opens things up a bit. 

[strachanmcgheegoal]

1 minute ago, aberdeen1970 said:

I was only considering what I'd call main strikers too. 

If we're including other 'forwards' then that opens things up a bit. 

A young Eoin Jess for instance.  And Booth even more so.

[aberdeen1970]

Aye. Jess, Jarvie, McGhee would be in contention then. 

[Dons21]

Gary Hackett

[Zeus]

If we are classing Jess as a striker then he's in my top 5

[Dons21]

Keith Edwards

[ericblack4boss]

In Brian Cooneys book he spoke to Jimmy Mullen and he openly states it was the board who signed Nicholas rather than Porterfield

[Simply Red]

Makes my eyes bleed seeing the likes of Lee Miller and Vernon on these lists.

As far as so-called shite strikers we’ve had, I thought Zdrillic and Di Rocco werent too bad compared to some of the clowns around them. Dadi was decent (good chant too)

None of you young team got Rory Fallon on yir list? Sure i saw him hit an absolute pearler on the volley from about 35yrd out. He was otherwise honking.

 

[Dynamo]

5 minutes ago, Simply Red said:

Makes my eyes bleed seeing the likes of Lee Miller and Vernon on these lists.

As far as so-called shite strikers we’ve had, I thought Zdrillic and Di Rocco werent too bad compared to some of the clowns around them. Dadi was decent (good chant too)

None of you young team got Rory Fallon on yir list? Sure i saw him hit an absolute pearler on the volley from about 35yrd out. He was otherwise honking.

 

I detested David Zdrillic. He couldn't be arsed and it showed.

 

[Simply Red]

1 minute ago, Dynamo said:

I detested David Zdrillic. He couldn't be arsed and it showed.

 

Tbf i was hammered for most games i attended in them days. Broadhill Bar early 2000s. My recollections are sketchy at best. 

[ollie1903]

I can only presume folk having Dodds, Vernon, Stavrum and Windass in a top 5 AFC strikers list are absolutely ripping the piss 

[V for Vendetta]

I think probably:

Shearer

Nicholas

Gilhaus

Jess

Booth

 

Or something along those lines.

Archibald, McGhee, Jarvie, McDougall, Harper all before my time.

[strachanmcgheegoal]

Yes.  Hopefully.

[WesthillWanderersFC]

4 minutes ago, ollie1903 said:

I can only presume folk having Dodds, Vernon, Stavrum and Windass in a top 5 AFC strikers list are absolutely ripping the piss 

Either that or it’s a pretty depressing list from the last 20 years or so. 

[Zeus]

Revised list

Jess

Shearer

Paatelainen 

Booth 

Rooney. 

 

Like I mentioned previously, it's been a mostly grim selection of Strikers for me. 

For every Shearer, theres been about 10 Mike Newells or Leon Mike's 

[CalgaryDon]

44 minutes ago, ollie1903 said:

I can only presume folk having Dodds, Vernon, Stavrum and Windass in a top 5 AFC strikers list are absolutely ripping the piss 

For those who have been watching since 1999 onwards unfortunately no. 

[muttonhumper]

8 hours ago, Simply Red said:

Tbf i was hammered for most games i attended in them days. Broadhill Bar early 2000s. My recollections are sketchy at best. 

Was so handy for those pre match scoofs.

Also handy for a half time pint when fucked up.

Or when the performance was so intolerable, the ejector seat was required.

 

McDougall

Shearer

Harper

Gillhaus

Archibald

 

For me.

 

 

[Guest]

15 hours ago, Millertime said:

Those last 2 posts, horrific chat

-6 on that last post wee man

[jamiesd]

Mcdougall

Harper

Shearer

Gillhaus

Black