Jump to content

Assessment

barassie_afc

By barassie_afc,
in AFC and Scottish Football

Recommended Posts


  • Replies 81
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Ke1t Grand Master

Ke1t

Posted
Posted

Well, there's no real School for Managers as such, so they need to learn primarily from their mistakes.

 

My position regarding McInnes has thus far been of folded-arm skepticism, He did well in Scotland, relatively, went to England and crashed and burned. That puts him on a downwards trajectory as far as I'm concerned, and I'm not forgetting he was the cheapest option either. But that's how Aberdeen rolls these days... If it's cheap enough it's good enough. That's what brings the glory days back, and no fucking mistake.

 

Having said that, he appears to be willing to learn from those aforementioned mistakes. Unlike the previous muppet, who was in his 70s and still played the same ultra-defensive, not-lose-at-all-costs, drawmageddon football he did back when he was the Scotland manager and probably even before that.

 

If DM continues to act to fix things that clearly don't work then he shouldn't be too terrible.

 

Jury is out on McInnes as far as I'm concerned, largely because he's not even completed his first season in charge.

 

I have no idea why he thinks Vernon or McGinn are wingers, though. Chris Clark is more a winger than Scott Vernon, though by the same token my last dog was a better winger than Chris Clark. So you would think McInnes would think to himself, Either I play Vernon through the middle or not at all.

 

Where was Zola today, btw.

 

Someone please tell me he's been sent back to the lower leagues.

Link to comment
Stoneybloke Collaborator

Stoneybloke

Posted
Posted

Enough of this negativity. It's far too early to make any conclusions about McInnes and his team. As someone said earlier, on paper the squad looks great, but not so good in actual matches. You have to concede that there are lots of other very capable teams in the SPFL, and sometimes we will win a game, other times we will lose. It's impossible to win them all so no point in being disappointed about it, but no reason not to have a moan just the same. McInnes knows what's wrong, but can he fix it, yes he can. Might take a few years though.

Link to comment
Ke1t Grand Master

Ke1t

Posted
Posted

I'm not being negative... I'm actually being positive.

 

DM seems to learn from his mistakes.

 

We're 3 points and three places better off than I was expecting (so far)

 

He's not Craig Broon.

 

He may have dropped Zola.

 

We're a better standard of mediocre than the standard of mediocre I expected.

 

These are all (relatively) massive plusses.

Link to comment
Bamber Collaborator

Bamber

Posted
Posted

Think its the players we are missing more than anything

 

Reynolds I don't think organises very well and not a good captain, we need Anderson back in there - just not sure where

 

We also seem to have swapped about a bit from last year - we look good at home but poor on the road. we don't look good with midfielders who run at us and we need to sort that out.

Link to comment
muttonhumper Mentor

muttonhumper

Posted
Posted

I'm surprised a throwing-the-toys-out-of-the-pram thread took so long to appear post match actually.

 

It's 100% valid given the last 2 performances against the 2 worst teams in the league. Well...they were the worst until we gave them both a hefty up.

 

Monday was horrendous.

Yesterday, believe me, was that x 5 or 6.

Link to comment
Foster14 Apprentice

Foster14

Posted
Posted

Unbeaten in 6 games in a row.

 

 

 

How many games are we unbeaten out of a row?

 

I don't really have an opinion yet. Approximately 50% disappointed that I won't be at the United game, have equal belief that I might see a good game with a good Aberdeen performance as I would that we'll see a shite game with a shite Aberdeen performance.

 

Guess we have another international break to work on the weaknesses.

Link to comment
Jocky Balboa Proficient

Jocky Balboa

Posted
Posted

It's 100% valid given the last 2 performances against the 2 worst teams in the league. Well...they were the worst until we gave them both a hefty up.

 

Monday was horrendous.

Yesterday, believe me, was that x 5 or 6.

That bad?! Christ, I was thinking of getting an ST when I'm back in the Granite City in a few weeks. After the last 2 games, I'm not so sure...

Link to comment
fine-n-dandy Grand Master

fine-n-dandy

Posted
Posted

That bad?! Christ, I was thinking of getting an ST when I'm back in the Granite City in a few weeks. After the last 2 games, I'm not so sure...

Whilst the club need your support I would strongly urge you to just PATG at this stage in the season rather than getting a ST.

Club still has a lot to prove.

Link to comment
Ke1t Grand Master

Ke1t

Posted
Posted

We need a good striker to play alongside McGinn

strikers have been our problem for a number of years

 

 

 

P.S Zola is on the same level as Mackie was

 

From what I've seen, Mackie would be a better option.

 

And he's free....

 

...don't rule it out.

Link to comment
fine-n-dandy Grand Master

fine-n-dandy

Posted
Posted

Whilst the club need your support I would strongly urge you to just PATG at this stage in the season rather than getting a ST.

Club still has a lot to prove.

 

 

Idiot

Excuse me? Why so regarding that statement? or is it just in general?

If just in general then :dontknow::laughing:

 

What is wrong with urging a fellow fan not to blow money on a ST prematurely?

 

If he just goes for PATG the club still gets his money & he decides when the club deserves that cash.

It's up to the club to put on the show to justify bringing the fans back all the time.

 

I'm a ST holder & have been for many years but if any "returning fans" ask my opinion at the moment well I wouldn't tell them to just blindly throw their money at the club unless they are not bothered about the concept of value for money.

 

I don't mind wasting the cash personally but wouldn't urge someone else to do so unless they sampled it first.

Link to comment
fine-n-dandy Grand Master

fine-n-dandy

Posted
Posted

I think the Falkirk game was a bit of a red herring, in the sense that we played a young team playing expansive football - whereas we really needed to grind out the results in the last couple of games despite some folk thinking we could just turn up and win by several goals.

 

Started the season with cautious optimism and I'm still at the same place now.

Falkirk game meant nothing regarding the league performances. Cup game so not really a good game to use to gauge our form.

 

I thought we should be beating the likes of St Mirren & County because we beat ICT (even though they were not great that day) & should have taken that momentum into these games & taken full advantage of it.

We underperformed in both the next league games. St Mirren was horrid to watch but they had more fight. County (the worst defence in the league) is just embarrassing.

 

I've been pleasantly surprised with a lot of things about Aberdeen this season (including DM) but they have sadly let us down in what could/should be classed as the "easiest" games yet again

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...