Jump to content

Scottish Independence Referendum 2


Henry

Should Scotland be an independent country?  

273 members have voted

  1. 1. Should Scotland be an independent country?

    • Yes
      197
    • No
      76


Recommended Posts


Could it maybe be that the 'Jeremy Kyle crew' perhaps feel failed by our political system and faced with a choice of change or the status quo voted for change. Easier to just sneer at folk though.

If they felt failed then surely that failure is westminister's failure not the EU. Unless rich people made them blame the EU and with it the migration of foreigners to these shores. Simply feeling failed isn't a justification for supporting Brexit. If anything that feeling could get worse when they don't have the same worker's rights nor human rights should Westminster choose to change that.

Link to comment

If they felt failed then surely that failure is westminister's failure not the EU. Unless rich people made them blame the EU and with it the migration of foreigners to these shores. Simply feeling failed isn't a justification for supporting Brexit. If anything that feeling could get worse when they don't have the same worker's rights nor human rights should Westminster choose to change that.

They wouldn't have them if the EU chose to change them either.

 

The very people they feel failed by and mistrust all told them one thing and they chose to go against that. No surprise really.

Link to comment

If they felt failed then surely that failure is westminister's failure not the EU. Unless rich people made them blame the EU and with it the migration of foreigners to these shores. Simply feeling failed isn't a justification for supporting Brexit. If anything that feeling could get worse when they don't have the same worker's rights nor human rights should Westminster choose to change that.

People's opposition to EU membership has been consistent for many years. The original project was for a free trade bloc rather than a sovereign entity whose laws we are subject to, people understandably don't think it's a good thing. Pro EU types don't care or positively want greater unification as is the EU project goal, an EU army etc. Others prefer sovereign nation states who trade with each other on mutually beneficial terms. I've always been fond of the EU and wasn't fussed with the spike in immigration. However I tend to think the future will revert to nation states working together in Europe and I think this will be a good thing for stability in the region

 

 

The mass increase in immigration during Blair years was also not particularly popular and changed society significantly, particular impact on workers on lower paid jobs and manual positions. It's not racist to want to control immigration, it's normal. Japan only had 18 immigrants last year are all Japanese racist?

 

Also the idea that we rely on EU for workers rights is daft, Westminster is more accountable to the people than lawmakers in Brussels.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment

Brexit or Scottish Independence will make absolutely fuck all difference to anyone’s life.

 

Why all this money has been spent is beyond belief.

 

It’s nae like suddenly Sturgeon is going to be firing out loads of cash to working class families or because we don’t have European workers in the country we’ll be better off and taxes will go down.

 

Complete waste of everyone’s time and money, we’re Scottish, British and European. Who actually gives a fuck. We’re not exactly appeased.

  • Downvote 1
Link to comment

Brexit or Scottish Independence will make absolutely fuck all difference to anyone’s life.

 

Why all this money has been spent is beyond belief.

 

It’s nae like suddenly Sturgeon is going to be firing out loads of cash to working class families or because we don’t have European workers in the country we’ll be better off and taxes will go down.

 

Complete waste of everyone’s time and money, we’re Scottish, British and European. Who actually gives a fuck. We’re not exactly appeased.

Fair bit of truth in this, point might be don't have referendums they stir up a world of shit.

  • Downvote 1
Link to comment

I wonder if Sturgeon has the self-awareness to see the dangerous precedent she is setting by constantly interfering in England and Wales democratic wishes and trying to overturn their result...

 

(Despite mainstream media horse shit to the contrary, they still appear to favour Leave, albeit very narrowly - the EU elections saw over 44% of votes go to Leave parties (Tories/Brexit/UKIP) versus 40% for Remain parties. The Brecon by-election, despite a LibDem pact with Remain parties, also saw more votes go to Leave parties)

 

What will happen if Scotland votes YES in Indyref2, but rUK spends 3yrs stamping its feet and whinging, refusing to accept the result?

 

If I didn't know better, I'd say she's still smarting from the arse kicking losses of 2017 (Scotland surely isn't as Europhile as made out, or we'd have banged down the door to independence by now?) and is trying to wiggle out of another referendum, then scrape through the 2021 election as a minority government. Another five years in power with such pathetic opposition? I'm sure she and hubby would love that.

  • Downvote 1
Link to comment

Once you leave the EU you will be raped by the US and have to follow their (much lesser) food standards rules. Talks are at quite an advanced stage with selling off the NHS to their private companies

 

Leave the EU but now you have to dance to the US tune

 

Idiots

But surely an enterprising UK chicken farmer will sell non chlorinated chicken and we can munch that?

Link to comment

As a side note however, I still believe in independence, on the principle of self-determination. The Tories haven't won the popular vote in any national election on Scotland since 1959 (and that was a conservative vote from two parties combined and they still got less seats than Labour) but have been in power two-thirds of the time since. For two-thirds of my life - and my parents' lives - Scotland has had a government it never voted for. At least under independence, we could get rid of Sturgeon and co. We are, however, stuck with BoJo the Clown and any other inept choice England makes.

Link to comment

Brexit or Scottish Independence will make absolutely fuck all difference to anyone’s life.

 

Why all this money has been spent is beyond belief.

 

It’s nae like suddenly Sturgeon is going to be firing out loads of cash to working class families or because we don’t have European workers in the country we’ll be better off and taxes will go down.

 

Complete waste of everyone’s time and money, we’re Scottish, British and European. Who actually gives a fuck. We’re not exactly appeased.

1. You think "making a difference" is all about money. Weird.

 

2. Quite a lot of folk "give a fuck", hence the debate. You sound like Bluto.

 

3. You don't know what "appeased" means.

Link to comment

As a side note however, I still believe in independence, on the principle of self-determination. The Tories haven't won the popular vote in any national election on Scotland since 1959 (and that was a conservative vote from two parties combined and they still got less seats than Labour) but have been in power two-thirds of the time since. For two-thirds of my life - and my parents' lives - Scotland has had a government it never voted for. At least under independence, we could get rid of Sturgeon and co. We are, however, stuck with BoJo the Clown and any other inept choice England makes.

One way of looking at it, however there are a fair few Scottish Tory MPs so plenty constituents at least represented in ruling party if not govt. Many other parts of the country could no doubt have a similar claim, Yorkshire for example.

  • Downvote 2
Link to comment

Just like the EU’s food standards rules (which are stringent and don’t allow for any shit entering the food chain) he would have to follow the US’s rules and chlorinate it - he won’t mind though as it will be cheaper for him to keep his chickens (and chicken meat) in rat infested shitholes.

 

Just disinfect the bastards

 

Yummy

 

Edit to add - the US farming lobby already have Bojo in their pockets (Corbz won’t allow it)

They don't HAVE to chlorinate it in the US they just don't stop people from doing it. It doesn't mean we'll all have to munch it. Total red herring(loved Fist of Fun)
Link to comment

Enjoy

 

I prefer my meat corn/grass fed with no chemicals

 

Thank you very mucho

 

(I get my bloody chemicals from other sources)

Me too but you will be eating 'chlorinated' food already. When I was a chef in Aberdeen we had to 'chlorinate' the lettuce. You might have eaten it, soz.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment

Mobz is exaggerating obviously but there's an element of truth in what he's saying.

 

We'll have to sign new trade deals with the US, on terms more favourable to the US than the one we have as part of the EU. Our marketplace will then be flooded with their cheap more poorly regulated food produce.

Link to comment

I'm not 100% convinced they will be lower. Our beef was banned by the yanks coz of CJD while we were still eating it. Its all just remainer hype. All food will still be labelled and we'll still be able to choose.

You're right moobs, why would our food standards lower? Chicken is washed in chlorinated water in the states to kill bacteria, it's not a lower food safety standard. There is no good reason not to do it.

  • Upvote 1
  • Downvote 1
Link to comment

1. You think "making a difference" is all about money. Weird.

 

2. Quite a lot of folk "give a fuck", hence the debate. You sound like Bluto.

 

3. You don't know what "appeased" means.

Yes I do, however fucked up as the the taxi was coming, actually meant oppressed but you got the Jist, was in between another conversation and meant appease the Nationalists.

 

So sell it to us? If it’s not about money, what is it about? We pretty much have self governance? What difference would me voting for independence make to my life?

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...