Jump to content

The Mckenna Dilemma


Recommended Posts

  • 2 weeks later...

Lol. McFadden in BBC interview.

 

Singles out Lewis Stephenson (& of course the new young tim) Lewis Morgan, O'donnell & McGeouch with credit for their Scotland games recently but not a single mention of McKenna, or Shinnie, or McLean, or Christie & any other newly capped players during the high number of call offs for Mexico & Peru.

Link to comment
Guest milne_afc

When we sell McKenna he should go for the same money he would if he were playing in the EPL.

 

Same player, same capability, same potential (regardless of current team or league).

 

21 year old Scotland captain.

 

Show us the money!!!

@@Millertime

Link to comment

Should Ronaldo have went to man Utd for same price as he went to Real?

 

I'm only talking about McKenna.

 

We shouldn't accept less for the same 'article'.

 

Why should (say) a Huddersfield be able to sell a McKenna for millions more than we can when he'd be the exact same thing in either location?

 

2 million is an insult.

 

Bidding starts at 10 million.

Link to comment

What are you, high?

 

Should Ronaldo have went to man Utd for same price as he went to Real?

 

Ronaldo cost Man Utd GBP 12 Million 14 years ago (19 years of age)

 

+ Real bought a 24 year old seasoned pro (47 CAPS)

 

Your comparison is inaccurate

 

should have been how much Real would have paid for the same 19 year old - there were other teams in for the 19 year old Ronaldo but did not cough the money

Link to comment

 

Ronaldo cost Man Utd GBP 12 Million 14 years ago (19 years of age)

 

+ Real bought a 24 year old seasoned pro (47 CAPS)

 

Your comparison is inaccurate

 

should have been how much Real would have paid for the same 19 year old - there were other teams in for the 19 year old Ronaldo but did not cough the money

 

Correct.

 

My comparison was between a 21 year old McKenna at Aberdeen and a 21 year old Scott McKenna at place like Huddersfield.

 

 

Not a player like Ronaldo at 2 different stages of his career 5 years apart.

 

Scotland regular who has also captained his country. £2million is an insult. If it was doubled plus a hefty sell on fee (15-20%) included in the contract then I'd say that was a fair reflection of his current value.

 

Agreed

Link to comment

And what, you think mckenna would just sit and stagnate at Swansea?

He would improve in the same style Ronaldo did you bloody simpleton

 

It's pointless talking about a 24 year old Scott McKenna now, though.

 

He'll improve just as easily at Aberdeen.

 

We'll have our own permanent training facilities up in 12 months, and in the meantime he'll be playing against the likes of Burnley, Celtic, Sevco, Hibs, Hearts, plus playing international games.

Link to comment

I agree that McKenna would improve more against more difficult competition, but that's not what we're talking about.

 

We're talking about how much we would sell him for now.

 

His age (21), potential, and accomplishments (regular starter, captaining Scotland, and winning goal of the season, etc.) all come into that.

 

How much would you sell him for?

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...